A leading Catholic academic has challenged Catholic universities to move beyond simply producing graduates for the workforce and instead focus on nurturing intellectual, spiritual, and cultural leaders who can become influential voices for the Church.
Speaking at the annual spring plenary meeting of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) in Orlando, mathematical biologist and Dartmouth University Provost, Santiago Schnell, expressed concern that despite the vast network of Catholic higher education institutions in the United States, Catholics remain underrepresented in the nation’s intellectual landscape.
According to Schnell, Catholic colleges and universities have gradually drifted toward imitating secular institutions, often prioritizing rankings, prestige, and professional training over faith-based formation and authentic Catholic identity.
He noted that while Catholic institutions educate hundreds of thousands of students annually, many fail to inspire graduates to become leaders who shape culture, scholarship, and public discourse through a distinctly Catholic worldview.
Schnell identified secularization as a major challenge facing Catholic higher education. He argued that many institutions have embraced values such as service, democracy, and social justice without maintaining a strong connection to faith and God, thereby weakening their religious mission.
He also criticized the influence of university ranking systems, describing them as a “rival magisterium” that encourages Catholic universities to measure success using secular standards rather than their unique spiritual and educational goals.
According to him, the true purpose of Catholic education extends beyond career preparation. It should cultivate thinkers, scientists, writers, theologians, and scholars who can enrich the Church’s intellectual tradition and contribute to society through faith-informed leadership.
Schnell emphasized that academic freedom must remain rooted in the pursuit of truth and cautioned against allowing personal ideologies to overshadow scholarly inquiry. He further stressed that institutional decisions—such as honorary degrees, commencement speakers, and senior appointments—reflect a university’s values and mission.
Drawing on the ideas of St. John Henry Newman, Schnell highlighted the importance of a university’s “spirit of place,” where faith, intellectual curiosity, and community life naturally intersect. He described this as the everyday conversations, shared beliefs, and spiritual culture that shape students beyond the classroom.
Concluding his address, Schnell urged the bishops to reflect on how Catholic higher education can recover its distinct identity, strengthen collaboration between universities and Church leadership, and create environments that inspire both academic excellence and spiritual formation.
His message served as a call for Catholic institutions to move from imitation to imagination, forming graduates who will not only succeed professionally but also become enduring voices for the Church and society.
EduTimes Africa, a product of Education Times Africa, is a magazine publication that aims to lend its support to close the yawning gap in Africa's educational development.